Why you shouldn’t make a game (or, why you should make a visual novel)

I recently stumbled across the following post on a game development forum:

Hey everyone! So I guess I’m looking for advice on how to start assembling a small team of people who want to create an Indie game. I’ve got the writing skills, but I don’t have any artistic or coding skills whatsoever. I have no idea where to start in the process of working on an Indie game. I’m especially worried that I have no money to pay anyone with, so this would be strictly to see if we could cobble together a game and get it sold on a platform.

At one point in time, I found this kind of post almost painful to read, but I’ve gradually become numb due to the frequency with which it repeats itself.  The common train of thought behind this post can be likely be reduced to, “I enjoy video games, and believe myself to be a pretty good judge of what constitutes a good video game.  I should get into game development!”  This makes about as much sense as deciding to become a novel-writer because you enjoy reading fiction, or become a film director because of your love of cinema.  Being an experienced consumer of content does not endow you with the skills required to create that content.

At the same time, there are is a visual interactive medium which many would-be game developers are qualified to create content for: visual novels.  Allow me to briefly explain why you, the person making the type of post described above, shouldn’t create a video game (and should make a visual novel instead):

You have no skill as a programmer

Coding is so foundational to game development that making a video game without any coding ability or experience seems inconceivable.  Trying to make a game without the ability to code is like trying to make a book without the ability to write.  An illiterate person could create a book by dictating the entire contents of their book to a literate person who then transcribed it (or more simply, by hiring a ghostwriter), but this is infeasible for a number of reasons.  First off, no one would be willing to do this for you without the offer of a sizable chunk of cash, which it doesn’t sound like you have.  Time and effort are much more finite than ideas, and your idea isn’t any more enticing than any of the other ideas out there.  Secondly, much of the process of creating a book comes through the process of internalizing your ideas as you transcribe them, and then re-iterating it so that it flows better.  Implementing your game idea through code allows you to understand, internalize, and critique it better in the same way that writing your ideas out on paper allows you to be a more effective writer.  By the finished product is time to publish, it may no longer be yours.  Further, the experience (and skill associated with it) will go to the person who is doing the execution, i.e. not you.

Visual novels, on the other hand, require little to no programming.  Ren’Py allows you to create visual novels with scripting so simple that I can’t think of a metaphor to adequately describe how simple it is.  At the same time, Ren’Py is powerful enough that, if you’re feeling ambitious enough, you can inject traditional game elements into it.  Simulation games and RPGs have been built using Ren’Py.

As an added bonus, after creating a visual novel in Ren’Py, you might just find that the process has taught you enough Python that you can begin coding an actual video game using Pygame or the like.  If even that is too much for you, NovelStream allows you to create visual novels using a graphical user interface with zero scripting.

You’re a writer, not an artist

It’s hard for a game, particularly one with low production value, to stand on its writing rather than its art direction or game design.  Studios like BioWare are lauded for their storytelling ability, but the effectiveness of the narratives woven within modern games like Knights of the Old Republic and Dragon Age is also in part due to their production value.  There’s more to BioWare’s storytelling than just writing.

Further, there are many examples of games, especially indie titles, which are virtually devoid of writing.  Games like Super Meat Boy demonstrate that writing can be an entirely dispensable element.  Even narrative-heavy examples like Bastion depend at least as much on good art direction and presentation as they do on writing.  In light of that, demand for writers among indie game developers tends to be lower than the demand for a programmer or a good art designer.  Thus, when attempting to join game development projects, you will likely find yourself at a disadvantage.  Writers will, at most, be one required part of the team, along side those who produce code and assets.  It’s hard to make yourself valuable as a writer.

There are a few scant examples of games whose existence is justified solely by their writing, but these are few and far between.  And interestingly, many of these titles (Planescape being the most notable), often crop up in discussions among the visual novel community with frequency that suggests that if your aim is to recreate Planescape, the medium to do so might be a visual novel, rather than a conventional video game.

Despite what the “visual” in “visual novel” might suggest, visual novels are actually quite capable of standing on writing alone.  Take, for example, Umineko no Naku Koro ni.  Umineko’s art assets and writing were all done by one man.  The finished product looks like this:

The the first episode of Umineko sold out within 30 minutes of its debut at Comiket 72, and the series has since spawned a manga series and drama CDs, as well as a 26-episode TV series.  To call Umineko “successful” would be putting it lightly.  One would presume that the success of Umineko is due to the writing, as the quality of the assets and other aspects of its presentation certainly didn’t do it any favors.

Your game idea isn’t actually a game idea

Jeff Wofford has written a very astute post on the subject of turning your idea into a game, and makes the following observation:

When people tell me their game ideas, usually their idea is 99% setting and story and only 1% gameplay. I have to tell them that they don’t have a game idea—they have a story idea. A game design is not a story design.  If you want your idea made into a game, you’ll have to fill out the details about how the game actually plays—what the player actually does, how he moves his character, how he interacts with the world.

Looking at games that are lauded for having immersive universes, such as Half-Life and Skyrim, the most interesting thing about these universes isn’t their content so much as how you are able to interact with it.  Take away the interactivity, and you no longer have a game.

The significant thing here is that the interactivity is the main draw for games, and the interactivity is not writing.  Writing often wrests control out of the hands of the players to tell its story, as is often seen in the case of cutscenes.  Some games try to disguise or hide this fact by offering nominal (fake) interactivity in the form of quick-time events.  And players hate them for it.

The point is that in order to make an effective game, your idea should be optimized for interactivity.  And odds are that if your main concern is effective story, you will wind up with ideas that optimizes for that instead.

Visual novels, much unlike games, often offer very little interactivity.  As an extreme example, Saya no Uta, despite being several hours in duration, offers the player only two decision points during the entire course of the narrative, a stark contrast from a game like Civilization where I expect to interact with the game hundreds of times per hour.  Some visual novels offer no interactivity and are completely linear, one Key example being Planetarian.

Recruiting people is hard (and you have no money)

So, you’ve decided that in spite of your lack of ability to program or produce assets, you’re going to create a game development team.  The question then becomes: who can you get to join your team?

Answer: probably not good game developers willing to work for free.  “Developer” tends to be a profession with relatively high demand, and a correspondingly high market value.  $50 per hour is on the low end of what you can expect to pay a freelance developer.  Similarly, good artists expect to be paid for their work.  When it comes to art, there’s a wider spectrum “acceptable” qualities (and prices to go with them), to get a good idea of what’s available, browse around the Deviant Art jobs forum.

Perhaps the most distressing part of this process is that, as discussed above, while writers can be dispensable parts of game creation, developers are not.  Without someone to code your game, you will, at most, be developing the idea for a game.  Your involvement in the process is contingent entirely upon the participation of others.

Creating a good visual novel still requires a sizable chunk of time and effort, not to mention skill in storycrafting.  However, unlike game development, visual novel development is something that is achievable for many people with the resources immediately available to them.  In a visual novel development, the most essential participant in the development process (and oftentimes, the person who invests the greatest amount of time) is the writer.  You may choose to recruit an artist or a general engineer along the way, but recruiting other people for your project is non-essential.  You can do it alone.  And you can do it now.

17 thoughts on “Why you shouldn’t make a game (or, why you should make a visual novel)

  1. I would add that text-based interactive fiction is another way for someone with a story idea to try fleshing it out into a game. Obviously art skills are not required and Inform 7 is specifically designed for use by non-programmers — and you get the bonus of being able to experiment a bit more with interactivity than you would in a visual novel. (Not trying to bag on visual novels, but so far as I know they don’t use a world model like IF does, just narrative branches.)

    • I wasn’t aware that visual novel development was such a popular subject; one of the main reasons I started this blog is because I consider the English-speaking visual novel development community to be underdeveloped. If there are other sites or articles which discuss this topic, I’d very much enjoy seeing them; would you mind linking?

  2. Excellent article! I wholeheartedly agree with everything you said. Games aren’t just about creating a cool story with scripted explosions.

    It’s annoying when a super-ambitious gamer who lacks the ability and experience to create games thinks that they can make a game. In fact, in a sense, it’s even a bit insulting. It’s like they’re saying, “If this person can design a game, so can I!” I’m also reminded of those “Can you believe we’re getting paid to make/play games?!” commercials from Westwood and the like. It’s like, “Yeah, you get paid to make games…if you actually know what goes into making one.”

    As a student majoring in Simulation & Digital Entertainment at The University of Baltimore, I can say that it ain’t easy. It’s been a long journey of 4+ years (I’m graduating at the end of this year), so I know firsthand that designing a game isn’t a walk in the park. I have taken programming (since it’s required), but it’s definitely my weakest skill. My main talents are writing (both story *and* gameplay, of course) and art (mostly concept art and graphic design).

    By the way, I have actually made a project in Inform 7 (a program for making text adventures) before. It was what we were assigned to do last year in Game Concept & Design. It’s pretty accessible compared to other programs and game genres, so I do think those story fans could get a kick out of it. Though it still requires thought; you have to map out the area (which the player can’t see since there are no graphics), you have to provide the player with enough descriptions, etc. In some ways, it’s *more* challenging than a game with graphics! It was certainly an experience I learned from.

    Once again, I enjoyed the article. Great job! :)

  3. Still, a lot of this sounds like stomping on a person’s ambitions. If someone took a lot of time and effort to write a game, it would crush them to read this article because it basically says they’re worthless and the developers are all that matter. Maybe explain how to put writers in contact with developers to pitch ideas?

  4. I don’t see this as “crushing a person’s ambitions.” If anything, it is injecting reality. The author provides suggestions for a writer: make a visual novel, or learn programming, and maybe do both at once.

    Also, if you have not thought through gameplay, and especially if you don’t REALIZE you need to think through gameplay when creating a game, I respectfully submit it is not realistic to create one.

    • I completely agree with this sentiment. I can respect the effort put into the article but it feels a bit too dismissive. Just because you’re not a game developer doesn’t mean you don’t still want to make a game. Someone who likes cinema and wants to make a movie should go study film making, A fiction lover should be guided learn how to write or at least learn the literary tools used in the effort of writing.

      Yeah a person might only have a story idea and a setting, but these days that’s what sets FPS-X from FPS-Z, the idea that you have might actually make the difference between a generic platformer and something a bit more original. These people aren’t asking for a patronizing pat on the head, they’re asking for help in how they can make that game. Sure if their dream is crushed after you explain what they need to make that happen then that’s that and maybe you can suggest VNs then, but they should be given the option rather than shoving them off to a interactive genre that has such a tiny niche even VN producers are complaining.

      • Weird, that should have been a reply to the comment above this one. Because it’s not injecting reality, injecting reality would be telling them how VNs don’t sell well unless you write in Japanese.

        • Thats not true! I’ve seen English visual novels sell quite well. Japanese is better as visual novels are more popular in Japan but doesn’t have to be in Japanese.

  5. Hey, I’m working with a small group of friends on a possible VN. It would be nice to talk and find out more about what your goals are with such a project. (ie. if you already had ideas and what your background might be)

    djausterlade@yahoo.com

    Just send me something and we can talk.

    • As a side note. I can’t give you any estimate on when we actually plan to finish such a project, this is just something we are doing for our own enjoyment.

  6. Thank you for posting this. It’s an articulate reminder that big ideas are never enough. But…

    This makes about as much sense as deciding to become a novel-writer because you enjoy reading fiction, or become a film director because of your love of cinema. Being an experienced consumer of content does not endow you with the skills required to create that content.

    I certainly hope a novelist becomes a novelist because he enjoys fiction. I certainly hope a director becomes a director because she enjoys cinema. I certainly hope both people are talented. Then I have something to enjoy, right?

    I also certainly hope being an educated consumer of content–in this case, an insightful gamer–is a necessary part of making good games. I want people who love games making them. This applies to programmers. It applies to artists. It also applies to writers.

    And all my favorite games have good writing.

    Please continue posting, and thanks for taking the time to put this post together. The “arrow to the knee” jokes in the IGN forums are driving me nuts!

  7. There are many valid points in this article.

    As an amateur novelist with a VN in the works, I can say that even such a task is formidable.

    I am currently handling script, programming, and music, with a two-artist team for backgrounds and characters. The music, as it follows a magical, trance-like theme, is easy for me to create through synthesized sound. However, even still, I have put around 100 hours into the soundtrack alone (over about four weeks).

    My script has clocked in at around 17,000 words, and I’m currently hunting editors to proofread before I code in the dialogue. Once again, this has already consumed a terrifying 300 hours of my time alone. Add that to the music, and we’re nearing four hundred hours of solitary work. This is on top of my studies, so you can see how quickly time gets away.

    I foresee a good six months before my project reaches completion, and that will take hundreds more hours of collaborative work.

  8. in my country – if we have enough lucky -I can find some artist who accept make one bust shot/ CG/ background/ for only from 15 – 50 $. I think it won’t too difficult to make one Visual Novel with 500 $, if you know how to using your money.

  9. I have to agree that this isn’t a positive post. After reading it I’m filled with negative emotions. It seems like the writer is annoyed and angry with other posters than wanting to help or give any advice. It all begins with the title “you shouldn’t”. A continues with “You” through out all the paragraphs by definition is patronizing.

Leave a Reply to Kuiper Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published.

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>